Curing Car Vs. Cyclist Road Wars With A New Rule: "Just Don't Steal The Right-Of-Way"

This blog article featuring Bob Mionske has been reproduced here for our media archives. To access the original article, follow the link.

Treehugger: Curing Car Vs. Cyclist Road Wars With A New Rule: "Just Don't Steal The Right-Of-Way"
by A.K. Streeter, Portland, Oregon on 08.18.11
CARS & TRANSPORTATION (bikes)

Though a world-class cycling city, Portland lacks a bike share system similar to those in other great cycling cities such as Minneapolis, Montreal, Paris, Barcelona. Though bike sharing is considered to be important to attract new cyclists onto the lanes, lack of funds has hampered planning efforts. At first, 2011 seemed to be the year the city of Portland would fund bike sharing. But then, as a vote neared, opposition arose from Commissioner Amanda Fritz, who claimed she couldn't support funding bike sharing due to...bad bicyclist behavior.

"I may support a bike sharing program downtown when I see bike riders using downtown streets and sidewalks in a safe manner. Daily, I see cyclists in the Light rail and bus lanes in front of my office. I see cyclists riding on the sidewalks, endangering and harassing pedestrians. I see cyclists running red lights and making illegal turns off the bus mall. And these are presumably experienced cyclists. I believe a bike rental program downtown would only add to these unsafe behaviors." - Amanda Fritz, via Bike Portland

Though the idea of withholding funding to a system until all users agree to strictly follow the rules is a new line of logic (imagine canceling road improvements until car drivers were caught speeding), bashing scofflaw cyclists, or course, isn't unique to Portland or Commissioner Fritz.

In fact, holding cyclists to a "different standard" is rampant, says bicycle attorney Bob Mionske, author of the book Bicycling and the Law.

"It is hypocritical, but cyclists are held to a different standard," Mionske said. "Meanwhile, 7 out of 10 motorists admit to breaking the law."

Of course, cyclists also break the law. As reported in the New York Times, students of Hunter college did two separate on-street studies of bicyclist behavior. In their most recent 2009 survey, they found that cyclists "routinely" (37%) rode through red lights. Around 10 percent of the more than 5,000 cyclists observed rode against traffic.

And while on the subject of lawbreaking, a PEMCO poll found that about a third of drivers admitted to jaywalking when they are pedestrians.

But because urban cycling is on the upswing in a selected number of U.S. cities, the question is whether scofflaw behavior is deepening the so-called rift between motorists, bicyclists, and pedestrians.

A recent Marist poll in New York City, where bike lane installations have caused protests, doesn't have a complete answer but some interesting tidbits.

First off, in spite of the much publicized bike lane conflict, the poll found a majority of New Yorkers - 66% of adults - support the bike lanes.

The poll also asked respondents which groups were "mostly respectful or not respectful when sharing the roads"? Those polled considered taxi drivers to be the least respectful (78% not respectful); motorists were next (53% not respectful), followed by bicyclists (46% not respectful) and pedestrians last (44% not respectful).

These are both encouraging and discouraging figures. On the one hand, they demonstrate that those on bikes are neither much better nor much worse than others when it comes to showing respect to fellow road users.

On the other hand, it seems like overall civility in traffic is a fairly scarce commodity.

How to improve? Well, Bob Mionske said there's only one golden rule consisting of just six words, and it applies equally to motorists, cyclists, and pedestrians.

"Don't steal the right of way." - Bob Mionske, BicycleLaw.com

P.S. Though Commissioner Fritz voted "no" on the initiative to fund Portland bike sharing, it was passed yesterday - see BikePortland.org for details. 

Comments (Comment Moderation is enabled. Your comment will not appear until approved.)
I am very enjoyed for this side. Its a nice topic. It help me very much to solve some problems. Its opportunity are so fantastic and working style so speedy. I think it may be help all of you. Thanks.
# Posted By Carbon Handle Bars | 11/16/11 6:57 AM
i like your awesome information
<a href="http://www.customessayhelp.com/research-paper-writ... paper help</a>
# Posted By davidvorner | 3/15/12 7:52 AM
"It is hypocritical, but cyclists are held to a different standard." I definitely agree. http://www.gotcellulitetreatments.com/cellulaze-ba...
# Posted By Jane | 4/9/12 10:44 PM
Always prefer to read the quality content and this thing I found in your post. Thanks for sharing.
http://www.searchmechaniks.co.uk/seo-leeds/ | seo leeds
# Posted By callum | 7/14/12 2:51 AM
visit forex pip for more great tips and tricks.
# Posted By forex pip | 8/6/12 3:38 AM
Thanks for posting this informative post. I like the content because its very easy to understand. And the topic captures my attention. Keep on posting like this and more power!
check this site also fx pips
# Posted By fx pips | 8/16/12 5:16 AM
Hello and thanks for posting this useful info. The article is very well structurated and written in a professional way, I appreciate the writer' s point of view and would like to congrats for the work he did so far. I will bookmark this site for future references. Thanks. <a href="http://www.x-y.ro">Octav</a>;
# Posted By Octav | 9/24/12 6:58 AM
Hello and thanks for posting this useful info. The article is very well structurated and written in a professional way, I appreciate the writer' s point of view and would like to congrats for the work he did so far. I will bookmark this site for future references. Thanks. <a href= "http://www.x-y.ro"; > Octav </a>
# Posted By Octav | 9/24/12 6:59 AM
regulated forex brokers have membership of a regulated financial authority. This requires that their company activities are monitored and that they adhere to a strict set of criteria set out by the regulatory body in order to run their business.
# Posted By Lyka | 10/24/12 12:52 AM
I am very enjoyed for this blog. Its an informative topic.
# Posted By article submission service | 10/27/12 7:24 PM
Michael Kors hamilton outlet,http://www.handbagsale.ca/
# Posted By michael kors outlet | 11/16/12 4:59 AM
regulated forex brokers have membership of a regulated financial authority. This requires that their company activities are monitored and that they adhere to a strict set of criteria set out by the regulatory body in order to run their business.
# Posted By regulated forex brokers | 11/20/12 6:07 AM
Thanks for sharing
# Posted By Nohalamshah | 11/26/12 11:56 PM
Hi, this is a very interesting web page and I have enjoyed read­ing many of the arti­cles and posts con­tained on the web­site, keep up the good work and hope to read some more inter­est­ing con­tent in the future. Thank you so much.
# Posted By <a href="http://vagyontanacsado.org/" | 11/26/12 11:57 PM
Your post is so interesting and informative. I got a lot of useful and significant information. Thank you so much.
<a href="http://tvzapping.org/"; rel="dofollow">seo consulting</a>
<a href="http://wolfimages.org/"; rel="dofollow">seo website</a>
# Posted By seo firm | 11/26/12 11:59 PM
Thanks for such a great article here. I was searching for something like this for quite a long time and at last Ive found it on your blog. It was definitely interesting for me to read about web applications and their market situation nowadays. thanks one more time and keep posting such nice ones in the nearest future too.
http://k-statefml.com/
http://my-giftstore.com/
http://zhonghao-hotel.com/
http://adoringrachelbilson.org/
http://blog-tp.com/
http://chapmanfml.com/
http://csufml.com/
http://mp3kafesi.net/
http://mundoadicto.com/
http://s2sproduction.com/
# Posted By blog post | 11/27/12 12:00 AM
Thanks for sharing great valuable data,which could support men and women primarily based to their want, like correct info, most effective education,right career,most recent news and mostly all needs of human currently being we are able to get right here.
http://www.parajumpersjacketsca.com/
# Posted By Parajumpers Jackets | 11/27/12 9:17 AM