Skip to main content

After Death, Manslaughter Charge For Cyclist

By June 15, 2012October 17th, 2021No Comments

The New York Times: After Death, Manslaughter Charge for Cyclist

Published: June 15, 2012

SAN FRANCISCO — Despite its hilly topography and hairpin curves, San Francisco has embraced the bicycle. In the last five years, the number of bikes here has jumped 71 percent. The city now ranks fourth (behind Portland, Ore., Minneapolis and Seattle) in the number of people who bike to work, according to the United States Census Bureau.

But a recent case of a bicycle-related death has set this cycle-loving city on edge. On Thursday, George Gascón, the San Francisco district attorney, announced that he would charge a bicyclist here with felony vehicular manslaughter for reckless riding that resulted in the death of a pedestrian.

On the morning of March 29, Chris Bucchere, a 36-year-old software developer, was riding his bike down a hill in the Castro District. Police officials say video from a nearby store’s surveillance camera put his speed as fast as 35 miles an hour.

Crossing a busy intersection when a traffic light turned red, Mr. Bucchere struck Sutchi Hui, 71, as he and his wife crossed the street. Both men tumbled some 20 feet along the street. Mr. Hui died of his injuries several days later.

News of the crash spread rapidly after people began sharing an online post on a cycling Web site that police officials believe Mr. Bucchere wrote. In the post, the writer describes the moments before the collision, saying he was “too committed” to stop at the light. “I laid it down and just plowed through the crowded crosswalk in the least-populated place I could find,” the post read. The entry goes on to detail the “river of blood on the asphalt” coming from Mr. Hui.

Though no agency tracks national data on the severity of charges in such cases, many cycling advocates and law enforcement officials said this was the first felony charge they had heard of in such a case.

“I’m hoping this case serves to raise awareness for everyone that the rules of the road apply to everyone,” said Mr. Gascón, who said Mr. Bucchere could be sentenced to up to six years in jail.

In a statement, Mr. Bucchere’s lawyer said he had turned himself in to the police and is cooperating with the investigation.

Some 4,834 cyclists and 59,925 pedestrians were killed by motor vehicles in the United States between 1999 and 2009 (the most recent year for which figures are available), according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Cyclists killed just 63 pedestrians, or about six a year, during the same time period.

The rarity of such cases is little comfort to residents in the area, where three people have been killed by cyclists in less than a year. The most recent victim was a 92-year-old woman killed on June 6 in a crosswalk in nearby El Cerrito, Calif., east of San Francisco.

Cases like these tend to generate feverish news coverage and amplify existing ire between cyclists and other road and sidewalk users.

“They think they own the streets,” said Pascal Bouchet, 53, who has been driving a taxicab in the city for 29 years. Mr. Bouchet said it is not just the oft-maligned bicycle messengers who are reckless, but the multitude of tourists who rent bikes to take in the sights. “They’re in vacation mode, spacing out, bicycling like they’re on the back roads in the south of France,” he said.

The majority of cyclists here follow the rules of the road, but some contend that a segment of riders knowingly flout the law. An editorial in The San Francisco Chronicle called these riders “aggro bikers,” while a commenter on another local news story about Mr. Bucchere labeled them “militant cyclists.”

But cycling advocates say such negative associations are based on outdated stereotypes. “We are seeing more and more people bicycling, and it’s not just 22-year-old aggressive males like it was 15 years ago,” said Leah Shahum, executive director of the 12,000-member San Francisco Bicycle Coalition. “Now it’s the moms, the tech workers, the lawyers, children, elderly people, teachers. It’s everybody.”

The number of trips made by bicycle in the United States more than doubled in the last decade, according to the United States Transportation Department and Federal Highway Administration. Meanwhile, the total number of cyclist fatalities has fallen by 21 percent since 1988.

“What you see is that as the number of bicycles goes up, the number of crashes goes down,” said Andy D. Clarke, president of the League of American Bicyclists. “There seems to be a safety in numbers effect.”

But pedestrian advocates say that as roadways become more crowded, more needs to be done to protect the most vulnerable: the bipeds without wheels.

Nancy Gruskin, 51, of Westfield, N.J., started a foundation to do just that after her husband, Stuart, was killed by a food delivery cyclist going the wrong way on a Manhattan street in 2009.

“What happened to my husband is rare,” said Ms. Gruskin. “But if you’re going to have more cyclists on the streets you need to do more to protect pedestrians.”